What buddy punching looks like
Buddy punching, or proxy attendance, is one person marking attendance for another. In a register book it is a signature. With a card machine it is a friend’s card in your pocket. With a PIN it is a number shared on WhatsApp. With a phone app it can be a borrowed phone or a fake location.
It matters because attendance becomes pay. A worker marked present for two extra days a month is paid for them, and their overtime may be too. Across 100 workers, a few proxy punches a week add up quickly.
Fingerprint, face, card, PIN and selfie with GPS compared
| Method | Stops proxy punching? | Where it fails |
|---|---|---|
| Card (RFID) | No | Cards are easy to lend. Use cards for doors, not for attendance on their own. |
| PIN or password | No | A number is shared in seconds. |
| Fingerprint | Mostly | Worn or cut fingers (masons, loaders, cooks) fail to read; staff then get a card or PIN “just for now”. Dirty sensors cause queues. |
| Face | Mostly | Contactless and quick. Cheap units without liveness checks can be fooled by a photo; check the model. Bright sun behind the person causes misses. |
| Selfie with GPS on the phone | Partly | Needs a smartphone. Proves place and gives a photo for review, but someone must look at flagged punches. |
| Supervisor marks on paper | Depends on the supervisor | Hard to audit later. |
The weak spot in most biometric set-ups is the exception. A fingerprint machine stops proxy punching until someone’s finger fails and they are given a card. Six months later, a fifth of the staff punch by card.
Which method to choose
- Factory or site with manual work
- A face machine. Fingerprints wear down with heavy work, and face reading is contactless.
- Office or shop
- Fingerprint or face. Both work well with clean hands and good light.
- Field staff, sales and service
- Selfie with GPS on the phone, in field mode, so the location is saved with each punch.
- Several small sites without a machine
- Selfie with GPS in office mode, with a geofence around each site.
- Doors
- Card or face for the door; attendance from the face or finger, not the card.
Many eSSL and ZKTeco machines let you set the verification mode on the machine, for example face only, or card plus fingerprint. Use it for anyone who has a card, so the card alone is not enough.
Checks that catch the rest
- Look at how each punch was verified. Card and PIN punches should be rare. A person whose punches are all card is the first one to check.
- Re-enrol failed fingers. Enrol two or three fingers, or move that person to face, rather than handing out a card.
- Walk the floor against the live list. Once a week, compare the people in front of you with the list of who is in right now.
- Watch patterns. Two people who always punch within a minute of each other, or a punch at the gate when the person was seen elsewhere.
- Review flagged phone punches. Punches outside the geofence or with poor GPS accuracy, and their selfies.
- Write it into your policy. State that punching for someone else is misconduct for both people, and apply it the same way every time.
How OTOMATE helps
OTOMATE records how each machine punch was verified: fingerprint, face, card, PIN, palm or app. The attendance log shows it beside every punch, and the console and app show who is in right now, live, so a floor check takes a minute. For phone punches, OTOMATE’s server refuses fake locations that Android reports from mock-location apps, fixes less accurate than your setting, punches outside the branch geofence in office mode, and repeat punches within a minute. HR can open each selfie and mark the punch approved or flagged. OTOMATE does not run face recognition on selfies, so a person still has to look.
More on the phone side in the guide to selfie attendance with GPS.