Blog

Cloud vs desktop attendance software: a fair comparison

Desktop attendance software runs on one office PC and pulls punches from the machine over your local network; it costs little, but the PC must stay on and you look after backups. Cloud attendance software has the machine push each punch over the internet to a server, so you see attendance from any phone and across branches, for a monthly fee. One site with one machine and one person doing payroll can manage on desktop; several sites or remote owners are better on cloud.

· Machines · 3 min read · By the OTOMATE team

How each one works

Desktop (pull)
Software such as eSSL’s eTimeTrackLite is installed on a Windows PC. The PC connects to the machine’s IP address on the office network and downloads the punches, on a timer or when someone clicks. Reports are made on that PC.
Cloud (push, ADMS)
You type a server address into the machine’s Cloud Server Setting, called ADMS on many eSSL and ZKTeco models. The machine dials out and sends each punch the moment it happens. You open reports in a browser or an app.

The machine is often the same in both cases. Most eSSL, ZKTeco, Realtime and Secureye machines sold in the last few years can do both. Only one cloud server can be set on the machine at a time.

Side by side

QuestionDesktop softwareCloud software
CostOften free with the machine, or a one-time feeA monthly or yearly fee per employee
Needs a PC on siteYes, switched on to collect punchesNo
Needs internetNo, within the officeYes at the machine; it stores punches while the line is down and sends them later
See attendance from homeOnly with remote-desktop toolsYes, from a browser or phone
Several branchesStatic IP, port forwarding or VPN at each branch, or one PC per branchEach machine dials out; all branches in one account
Where data livesOn your PCOn the vendor’s servers
BackupsYour jobThe vendor’s job; ask how often and where
UpdatesInstall them yourselfArrive on their own
Staff self-serviceRareCommon: leave, missed-punch requests, payslips in an app
If the vendor closesSoftware keeps runningExport your data regularly

When desktop software is enough

  • One site, one or two machines, all on the same network
  • One person runs attendance and payroll, from the office
  • Internet at the site is poor or absent
  • Someone is comfortable taking backups and keeping that PC healthy

The usual pain points are a PC that crashes or gets replaced, a database nobody backed up, and the owner phoning the office to ask who has come in.

When cloud software is better

  • More than one branch, site or gate
  • The owner or HR wants to see attendance from a phone
  • Field staff who punch from a phone as well as staff at a machine
  • Staff should apply for leave and see payslips themselves
  • Nobody wants to look after a PC, backups or Windows updates

Check before you choose a cloud vendor: whether your machine model can push to them, whether they store fingerprint templates (OTOMATE does not), how you export your data, and that punches made during an outage arrive with their real times.

Switching from desktop to cloud

  1. Export your old attendance from the desktop software to Excel and keep it.
  2. On the machine, open Cloud Server Setting (or ADMS) and enter the cloud server’s address and port.
  3. Add the machine in the cloud software by its serial number.
  4. Check that staff already enrolled on the machine appear. They should not need to enrol again.

With OTOMATE there is no PC, port forwarding or static IP. The machine dials out on port 80; punches arrive within seconds; staff already on the machine are picked up with their codes; and punches stored while the internet was down are sent with their original times. Step by step: connect an eSSL machine to the cloud.

Questions people ask

Something else? Call +91 90536 35607 or write to hello@otomateworld.com.

Is eTimeTrackLite cloud-based?

eTimeTrackLite is desktop software: it runs on a PC on your network and collects punches from the machine. To see attendance online, the machine’s Cloud Server (ADMS) setting is pointed at a cloud service instead.

Does cloud attendance stop working when the internet goes down?

No. The machine keeps taking punches and stores them in its memory, up to its storage limit. When the connection returns it sends them with the times they really happened.

Can I use desktop and cloud software on the same machine?

The Cloud Server Setting points at one server, so live punches go to the cloud service. Export your old records from the desktop software before you switch.

Do I need a static IP for cloud attendance?

No. The machine dials out to the server, as a phone opens a website, so it works behind an ordinary office router. Desktop software reaching a machine at another branch is what needs a static IP or VPN.

Is cloud attendance data safe?

It depends on the vendor. Ask whether fingerprint templates leave the machine, how each company’s data is separated, and how sign-in works. OTOMATE stores punches, never fingerprint or face templates.

See it on your own machines

Book a free demo. We connect one of your machines with you on a call, and you watch your own staff’s punches arrive.